Series

6 Series I Thought I'd Hate That I Loved (And 4 I Loved That I Now Don't)

Six series I bounced off initially that turned out to be excellent once I gave them a chance, plus four series I loved at the time that haven't held up. Honest reactions across years of TV watching.

On this page 15 sections
  1. 1 The 6 I thought I'd hate but loved
  2. 2 1. Succession
  3. 3 2. Bojack Horseman
  4. 4 3. The Bear
  5. 5 4. Severance
  6. 6 5. Andor
  7. 7 6. Reservation Dogs
  8. 8 The 4 I loved that haven't held up
  9. 9 1. Lost
  10. 10 2. Sherlock
  11. 11 3. Westworld
  12. 12 4. House of Cards
  13. 13 What the patterns suggest
  14. 14 What I now do
  15. 15 The takeaway

TV series taste is hard to predict. Some shows you bounce off initially that turn out to be excellent once you actually engage. Others you love at the time that don't hold up to memory. Here are six of each from years of TV watching, with what I've come to think about each.

The 6 I thought I'd hate but loved

1. Succession

I avoided this for two years because the premise (rich family squabbling) didn't appeal. Eventually watched. Realized it's actually one of the best shows of recent years — the writing is exceptional, the performances are extraordinary, the moral landscape is surprisingly complex.

The show is about more than rich family dynamics; it's about how power corrupts and how people sustain themselves in environments that don't support actual human connection.

2. Bojack Horseman

Skipped it because "talking horse" sounded ridiculous. Watched eventually. The show is one of the deepest explorations of depression and identity in television form. The animal-character framing turns out to enable rather than diminish the depth.

The middle seasons in particular are extraordinary. The show takes serious questions seriously while remaining funny.

3. The Bear

Resisted because "show about restaurant kitchen" didn't sound interesting. The show turns out to be about family, grief, and the weight of inheriting other people's dreams. The kitchen is just the setting.

The performances, particularly Jeremy Allen White and Ayo Edebiri, are exceptional. Worth watching.

4. Severance

The premise (workers who separate work and personal memories) sounded gimmicky. The show is much more than its premise — a meditation on identity, work, and what gives life meaning.

The visual direction by Ben Stiller is exceptional. The pacing is unusual but rewarding.

5. Andor

I had Star Wars fatigue. Avoided it. Eventually watched and was wrong. Andor is one of the best television series of recent years — political, literary, taking time to develop characters and themes the way most prestige TV doesn't.

The show works whether or not you care about Star Wars. It's a serious drama that happens to share a universe with Star Wars.

6. Reservation Dogs

I didn't know much about it. Watched on recommendation. The show is funny, sad, specific to its setting (Indigenous community in rural Oklahoma), and humanly substantial in ways most shows aren't.

The character work is exceptional. The show treats its specific cultural context as the source of its strength rather than as exotic backdrop.

The 4 I loved that haven't held up

1. Lost

Loved this when it aired. The mystery, the characters, the weekly anticipation. Tried to rewatch a few years ago. The show doesn't hold up — the mysteries weren't actually heading anywhere, the character work is uneven, the pacing is excruciating in retrospect.

Lost was a phenomenon of its moment. The show that aired in 2004-2010 isn't the same show that exists in retrospect.

2. Sherlock

The early seasons were brilliant when they aired. Recent rewatching reveals problems — the writing got worse across seasons, the cleverness became smug, the central character became less interesting as the show went on.

The first two seasons remain good. The later seasons did damage that retrospective viewing can't un-see.

3. Westworld

The first season was genuinely impressive. Subsequent seasons abandoned what worked in favor of increasingly elaborate plot mechanics that didn't support the philosophical questions the show originally engaged with.

The first season holds up; everything after doesn't.

4. House of Cards

I watched the early seasons obsessively. The political cynicism felt knowing and contemporary. Now the cynicism reads as tired and unconvincing; the show's insights about politics and power look superficial in retrospect.

The early appeal was partly about cultural moment. The cultural moment passed; what remains is less impressive.

What the patterns suggest

Looking at both lists, certain patterns emerge:

Shows with strong premises but weaker execution age badly. The premise that excites initially can't sustain when the execution doesn't hold up.

Shows with weak premises but strong execution age well. The execution carries the show across years; what initially seemed unappealing can become impressive when actually engaged with.

Cultural moment matters at viewing time but not in retrospect. Shows that captured cultural moments often don't hold up when the moment passes.

Character work survives better than plot mechanics. Shows whose value rests on plot mechanics tend to suffer in retrospect; shows whose value rests on character work tend to hold up.

What I now do

For new series:

  • Be willing to try shows whose premises don't initially appeal. Premise alone doesn't predict whether shows are good.
  • Give shows at least 3-4 episodes before judgment. Many good shows have weak first episodes.
  • Trust specific recommenders whose taste matches mine.
  • Be honest when shows don't work for me, even when culturally celebrated.

For shows I've loved:

  • Be willing to update opinions when rewatching reveals problems.
  • Distinguish between "loved at the time" and "actually good" — both are valid but different.
  • Recommend shows I currently believe in, not just shows I once believed in.

The takeaway

TV taste is harder to predict than most viewers acknowledge. Some shows you'll dismiss prematurely; some shows you'll love at the time but won't hold up. The honest engagement — being willing to try things and update opinions — produces better watching than committing too firmly to either initial impressions or past loves.

For your own watching, try one of the six I was wrong about. The show might be one you've been resisting unfairly. Or revisit one of the four that didn't hold up; you might agree with my retrospective assessment, or disagree productively.